Butterfly for mortals: the two-kick timing that makes it possible
Butterfly turns on where the two kicks land in the arm cycle. The published standards put the cost at 7 to 9 per cent over freestyle — a third of what breaststroke costs.

Butterfly has a reputation as the stroke for the strong, which is mostly wrong. It is the stroke for the well-timed. Get the rhythm right and it is hard work; get it wrong and it is impossible, regardless of how much you can bench.
Almost all of the difference is in where two kicks land, and the published time standards back that up: in the USA Swimming tables the 100 butterfly sits only 6.7% to 8.6% behind the 100 freestyle from age 13 up, against 13.8% to 29.1% at 10 and under. The stroke is not expensive. Not knowing it is.
What the rule book actually says about butterfly
Butterfly is the most tightly defined of the four strokes, and reading the actual articles is worth ten minutes because three of the commonest beliefs about it are not in there.
These are the World Aquatics Competition Regulations in force from February 2026, Part Two, Article 8.
| Article | What it requires |
|---|---|
| 8.1, 8.2 | Body on the breast from the first arm stroke after the start and each turn. No rolling onto the back, except at the turn after touching the wall. |
| 8.3 | Both arms forward simultaneously over the water, backward simultaneously under it, throughout the race. |
| 8.4 | All up and down leg movements simultaneous. The legs or feet need not be on the same level, but must not alternate. No breaststroke kicking movement. |
| 8.5 | Turn and finish touched with both hands separated and simultaneously. "Separated" means not stacked one on top of the other — no visible gap needed, incidental contact at the fingers allowed. |
| 8.6 | Some part of the body must break the surface throughout, except during the turn and for up to 15 m off each wall, where you get unlimited kicks but only one arm pull. |
Two things in there surprise people. Your feet do not have to be level — Article 8.4 says so explicitly, and what is illegal is an alternating action, not an uneven one. And one arm pull underwater, not two: the kicks off the wall are unlimited inside 15 m, the pull is not, and that is the rule most often broken by adults who learned the stroke informally. Breaststroke works the other way round — one pull, one kick, and no 15 m limit at all.
What the regulations remove is the improvisation available in other strokes: you cannot quietly turn a struggling butterfly into a modified freestyle. And because both arms recover at once, there is a moment in every cycle when nothing is propelling you. Everything depends on arriving at that moment with momentum.
Where the two rule books disagree, and it matters in a Masters meet
Article 8.4 of the World Aquatics regulations forbids a breaststroke kicking movement in butterfly outright. The 2026 U.S. Masters Swimming rule book says the opposite in article 101.3.3: the breaststroke kick "may be used exclusively or interchangeably with the dolphin kick while doing the butterfly stroke at any time during the race", at one kick per arm pull.
So the same stroke is legal at a USMS meet and a disqualification at a World Aquatics one. It is a deliberate Masters allowance for swimmers whose shoulders or backs will not take a repeated dolphin action — but it means knowing which rule set your event is swum under, and the entry information says so. The mirror-image detail, that a single dolphin kick is permitted in breaststroke off each wall, is in the breaststroke kick guide.
So if a coach suggests swimming butterfly with a breaststroke kick to protect a sore back, that is a real option in Masters competition rather than a training-only exercise — but check the meet rules before you count on it.
The two kicks, and what each is for
This is the core of it. There are two kicks per arm cycle, and they are not interchangeable.
Kick one lands as the hands enter the water at the front of the stroke. Its job is to press the hips up and set the body position for the catch. Miss it and you enter flat and low.
Kick two lands as the hands finish the pull and leave the water at the back. Its job is to drive the hips down so the chest and shoulders rise — which is what carries your arms up and over for the recovery.
The second one changes everything for adult learners. The recovery is not lifted by the shoulders. It is thrown by the second kick. If your arms feel like lead by the fourth stroke, this is almost certainly why: you are performing with muscle a movement that is supposed to be free.
The rhythm, out loud
A cue that works better than any description of angles. Count the cycle as kick — pull — kick — recover, or in the version people say on pool decks: kick your hands in, kick your hands out.
That single sentence is most of butterfly. The first kick goes with the hands going in at the front; the second with the hands coming out at the back.
The reason it beats a technical description is that butterfly happens too fast to think about. By the time you have decided where your hips should be, the cycle has moved on. A count runs underneath conscious thought, which is where a rhythm belongs — so say it in your head while you swim. It sounds simplistic and it is the fastest route to the timing.
Counting also gives you the only honest measure of whether the timing is improving rather than your fitness. Take the strokes and the time for one length together as SWOLF: when the kicks land in the right places, the same 25 costs fewer strokes at the same time, and the number drops. Read it only against your own previous butterfly, in the same pool and at the same effort — the published SWOLF bands describe freestyle in a 25 m pool and say nothing about a butterfly number, so there is no target here, only a direction of travel. The turnover-against-length trade-off is in stroke rate or stroke length.
The arms: less than you think
Because butterfly looks so physical, adults assume the arms are doing enormous work. They are doing normal work in an unusual pattern, and the pattern is the difficulty.
The pull is roughly a keyhole shape: hands enter about shoulder width, press out and back, sweep in under the chest, and accelerate out past the hips. The critical part is the finish — the hands should accelerate all the way past the hips before leaving the water, because that acceleration plus the second kick is what launches the recovery. A pull that stops short at the ribs leaves you lifting your arms from a dead position, and no amount of shoulder strength makes that comfortable.
The recovery itself should be low and relaxed, arms swinging around rather than lifting up, thumbs down or palms out, elbows soft. Adults tend to recover high and tense, which costs energy and puts the shoulders somewhere they do not enjoy over many repetitions.
If the arms are the part that fails first, the fault is nearly always upstream: a missing second kick, or a pull that does not finish.
The undulation, and where it should come from
Butterfly involves a wave through the body, and the wave is where most people injure themselves. It should be driven from the chest and hips, with a relatively small range, and the legs following — not produced by arching and flattening the lower back, which is what happens when swimmers try to make the wave bigger than it needs to be.
A useful correction: think of pressing the chest down rather than lifting the hips up. The same shape results, but the effort comes from a place that tolerates it.
And nothing in the regulations asks for a big wave. Article 8.4 only asks that the legs move together and do not alternate — the amplitude is yours to choose, and smaller is usually both faster and kinder.
Breathing without wrecking the stroke
The breath is where a decent butterfly falls apart, because lifting the head high enough to breathe drops the hips at exactly the wrong moment.
Two rules. Look forward and slightly down, not up: the chin stays close to the water and the eyes point at the surface a short distance ahead, not at the far wall. And get the head back in before the hands enter, so you are not entering with your head still up.
While learning, breathe every stroke. The advice to breathe every second stroke belongs to swimmers who already have the timing, and applying it early guarantees an oxygen debt that destroys the rhythm within five metres. An oxygen-starved swimmer cannot hold technique — the argument is made at length in how to breathe while swimming freestyle and it is even more true here.
How much slower butterfly actually is, in published numbers
Most of what gets written about butterfly being "the hardest stroke" is feel rather than measurement. The time standards let you put a number on it, because USA Swimming publishes cuts for the same population across all four strokes. Taking the 2024-2028 age group motivational standards and comparing each stroke's 100 against the 100 freestyle for ages 13 to 18, all six levels, both sexes and all three courses — 108 comparisons per stroke:
Butterfly is the second-cheapest stroke in the pool, measured this way: less than backstroke relative to freestyle, and roughly a third of what breaststroke costs. For a swimmer who finds butterfly exhausting and backstroke easy, that is useful information — the stroke is not the problem.
In seconds, at the A level for 17-18s in a 25-yard pool: girls 58.39 for the 100 free against 1:03.09 for the 100 fly, a gap of 4.7 s; boys 51.69 and 56.09, a gap of 4.4 s. Put your own times into the pace calculator and you can see whether your own fly-to-free gap is anywhere near that or three times as big — which is the timing telling you something.
The distance matters too, and not in the direction most people guess. The 100 is where butterfly is cheapest:
| Event | Gap over freestyle, short course | Gap over freestyle, long course |
|---|---|---|
| 50 fly | +9.0% to +12.0% | +6.8% to +9.0% |
| 100 fly | +8.0% to +8.6% | +6.7% to +7.7% |
| 200 fly | +9.6% to +11.5% | +9.2% to +11.7% |
The 200 is consistently the most expensive, which is what you would expect from a stroke whose cost is mostly timing: timing is the first thing fatigue takes away. That reading is an interpretation, not something the tables state — but the pattern itself is in the published numbers, in every course and at every level.
The gap that closes: what the children's tables show
The most revealing part of the standards is not the 17-18 band. It is what happens below it.
| Age group | 100 fly against 100 free | Width of the band |
|---|---|---|
| 10 & under | +13.8% to +29.1% | 15.3 points |
| 11-12 | +10.1% to +16.0% | 5.9 points |
| 13-14 | +6.9% to +8.6% | 1.7 points |
| 15-16 | +6.9% to +8.5% | 1.6 points |
| 17-18 | +6.7% to +8.6% | 1.9 points |
Two things happen at once. The gap shrinks by roughly two thirds, and the spread between the slowest and fastest cut almost vanishes. Inside the 10-and-under girls' table alone, the fly penalty is 28.5% at the B cut and 14.7% at the AAAA cut — same age, same distance, half the penalty.
Breaststroke does not behave like that. Its gap starts at 29.6% to 33.9% at 10 and under and is still 23.6% to 25.5% at 17-18: the stroke stays a quarter slower for life, because the glide and the recovery are built into it. Butterfly's cost is not built in — it is learned off.
There is a second marker in the same tables. At 10 and under, the 100 backstroke cut is faster than the 100 butterfly cut in 35 of the 36 published combinations. From 11-12 upwards it reverses: butterfly is the faster of the two in nearly every row, and in long course it stays faster through 17-18. Somewhere around 11 or 12, in a population that trains all four strokes, butterfly stops being the slow one — and nothing about those swimmers' strength changed that quickly. The time standards tool has the full tables, and swimming backstroke straight covers the other side of the comparison.
A 25 m pool against a 50 m pool
Butterfly is the stroke where the pool length changes the swim most, for a reason that is purely arithmetic: the underwater allowance is a fixed 15 m, so in a 25 m pool Article 8.6 lets you spend up to 60% of every length submerged off the wall — about 66% in a 25-yard pool — against 30% in a 50 m pool. A short-course 100 butterfly is four underwater phases and three turns; the long-course version is two and one. That is why strong dolphin kickers look like different swimmers in a short-course meet, and why how far the kick is worth holding is a question of its own — the same mechanism as in how to do a flip turn and short course against long course.
What the standards show, though, is the opposite of the naive expectation: the fly-to-free gap is slightly wider in short course (+8.0% to +8.6% in the 100) than in long course (+6.7% to +7.7%). Freestyle evidently gains at least as much from the extra walls as butterfly does. Why is not something the tables answer, and this guide will not invent a mechanism for it — but if you swim both courses, expect your butterfly to convert slightly worse than your freestyle, and use the course time converter rather than one rule of thumb for all four strokes.
How to learn it without a week of soreness
The mistake is to attempt lengths. Butterfly with bad timing costs several times what good timing costs, so lengths early produce exhaustion, poor technique and a sore back — and teach the wrong pattern. A sequence that works instead:
- Body dolphin, no arms. Arms at your sides or extended, undulating from the chest. The wave without any of the load.
- Single strokes. Push off, one full butterfly stroke, then stop and stand or glide. Repeat. One cycle's timing is the only thing that matters at this stage.
- Three strokes, then freestyle to the end of the length. Enough repetitions to find the rhythm, few enough that fatigue does not corrupt it.
- 25s with generous rest, once the three-stroke version feels rhythmic rather than effortful.
"Generous" is worth turning into a number, because in butterfly the rest is the part that protects the timing. Put your 25 time into the interval calculator and pick a send-off that leaves you resting at least as long as you swam. A freestyle set often runs on ten or fifteen seconds of rest; butterfly learned this way needs far more, and a send-off decides that instead of leaving it to a tiring swimmer's judgement.
Notice that lengths appear last. Butterfly is the one stroke where volume before technique is actively counterproductive, and the advice in should you swim every day about varying the stroke applies with extra force: a little butterfly, often, beats a lot of it occasionally. A reasonable dose while learning is 100 to 200 m spread through a session, in pieces of three to eight strokes, two or three times a week — enough repetition for the timing to consolidate and little enough that the stroke never degrades into flailing. It slots into the end of a warm-up rather than the middle of a main set; the swim warm-up guide has the shape of that.
When the timing still will not come
Most stalls are one of five things, each with a different fix. This is coaching consensus rather than measured science, which is worth saying plainly.
| What you feel | Usual cause | What to try |
|---|---|---|
| Arms will not clear the water by stroke three | Missing or late second kick | Single strokes, kicking deliberately as the hands leave. Exaggerate it. |
| You sink at the front of every stroke | Missing first kick, or head still up on entry | Body dolphin, arms extended; then one-arm fly. |
| Works for 15 m then collapses | Breathing pattern, not fitness | Breathe every stroke; shorten the repetition to three. |
| Legs feel like they kick in opposition | Flutter habit from freestyle | Vertical dolphin kick where you can stand up, hands on chest. |
| Lower back aches afterwards | Wave coming from the lumbar spine | Less amplitude; press the chest, do not lift the hips. If it persists, stop. |
One-arm butterfly deserves its own line, because it is the drill that most reliably rescues the timing: one arm pulls while the other stays extended in front, both kicks in their normal places, breathing to the side of the pulling arm. It halves the load and leaves the rhythm intact — and it is, usefully, close to impossible to do with a single kick per cycle.
The lower back, the shoulders, and when to stop
Butterfly loads two places harder than the other strokes, and it is worth knowing which signals mean "adjust" and which mean "stop".
Lower back pain during or after butterfly is a signal to reduce the range of the undulation and rebuild the stroke in short pieces, not to push through. Shoulder pain in the recovery is the same. Pain that persists after you stop swimming, pain that wakes you up, or any numbness or weakness in an arm, is a reason to see a doctor or a physiotherapist rather than a reason to change drills. Nothing in this guide is a diagnosis, and no amount of technique work fixes an injury that is already there.
The mechanism is different from swimmer's shoulder, an overuse problem from thousands of freestyle repetitions, but the rule about not swimming through it is identical. Butterfly's version tends to be acute and positional: it hurts in the recovery, at the top of the arm swing, and from the first session rather than building over months.
Two more things that are simply not worth doing. Do not practise the underwater phase by holding your breath for distance — the 15 m allowance is a racing limit, not a breath-holding target, and repeated maximal breath-holds in water carry a real risk of blacking out. And do not teach yourself butterfly alone in a quiet pool with nobody watching: the stroke is fatiguing in a way that arrives suddenly.
Why bother at all
A fair question if you are never going to race it. Two reasons. The undulation and the dolphin kick are what drive the underwater phase off every wall in every stroke, and that phase is worth real time — the rules allow up to 15 m of it, and it is covered in how to swim your 100 free faster. And it moves your shoulders through a completely different range from freestyle, which for an adult swimming several times a week is a genuine benefit rather than a nicety.
The other strokes are in technique, the sets in workouts, and the published cuts in times.
This is general technique information rather than coaching for your body. Butterfly loads the lower back and shoulders in ways that not everyone tolerates; if something hurts, stop and ask a professional. Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it and date the change.
Frequently asked questions
How many kicks are there per stroke?
Two, and they do different jobs. The first lands roughly as the hands enter the water at the front. The second lands as the hands finish the pull and leave the water at the back. Swimmers who kick once per cycle, or who kick at random, find butterfly enormously harder than it needs to be.
Why can I not get my arms out of the water?
Because you are asking your shoulders to do a job the second kick is supposed to do. That kick drives the hips down and the upper body up, and the recovery rides on that momentum. Without it you are lifting two tired arms out of the water with muscle alone, which nobody can sustain.
Is butterfly really the hardest stroke?
Not by the published numbers. In the USA Swimming motivational standards the 100 butterfly sits 6.7% to 8.6% behind the 100 freestyle from age 13 up, while the 100 breaststroke sits 23.6% to 26.1% behind. Butterfly feels hardest because bad timing is expensive, not because the stroke is slow.
How many dolphin kicks can I take off the wall?
As many as you like within the first 15 metres, but only one arm pull, and your head must break the surface by the 15 metre mark. That is World Aquatics article 8.6. The limit most adults break is the pull, not the kicks.
Is a breaststroke kick allowed in butterfly?
It depends on the rule set. World Aquatics article 8.4 forbids it. U.S. Masters Swimming article 101.3.3 allows it, one kick per arm pull, as a deliberate concession for swimmers who cannot repeat a dolphin action. Check which rules your meet is swum under.
Do I need to be strong to swim butterfly?
Less than you would think. Butterfly punishes bad timing far more than it rewards strength, which is why some slight swimmers make it look easy and some strong ones cannot complete a length. Strength helps at speed; timing determines whether the stroke works at all.
Why does my lower back hurt?
Usually because the undulation is coming from arching the back rather than from the hips, and often because the head is lifting too high to breathe. It is a signal to stop and rebuild the stroke in short pieces, not to push through — and if it persists, to see a professional.
Sources
- World Aquatics Competition Regulations, Part Two: Swimming Rules — articles 8.1 to 8.6 (butterfly), in force from February 2026 — World Aquatics
- 2026 U.S. Masters Swimming Rule Book, Part 1 — article 101.3 (butterfly), including the breaststroke-kick allowance in 101.3.3 — U.S. Masters Swimming
- 2024-2028 Motivational Time Standards, age group (revision of 10 October 2025) — USA Swimming
- U.S. Masters Swimming — Butterfly timing guide
- U.S. Masters Swimming — Butterfly kick and body position guides
- U.S. Masters Swimming — Underwater kick guide
Read next

Why do swimmers wear two caps? To pin the goggle straps down
The second cap covers the goggle straps and stops the first one wrinkling. Two caps is explicitly legal, and two is the written maximum — here is the rule.

What age should a child start swim lessons?
The official answer is the first birthday for lessons, but babies can be in water long before that. Here is where each health body draws the line, and why it matters.

Why swimmers get disqualified: the calls officials make
A disqualification is a procedure, not an opinion. Who is allowed to call one, what goes on the slip, what the code means, and how it can be challenged.
SwimFast is an independent publication. We are not a swim school, a coaching service or a governing body, and nothing here is medical advice. Training paces and test protocols are cited from the published research or federation documents linked on each page. Never swim alone, never attempt breath-hold work without supervision, and check with a doctor before starting a new training programme.