Butterfly for mortals: the two-kick timing that makes it possible

Butterfly turns on where the two kicks land in the arm cycle. The published standards put the cost at 7 to 9 per cent over freestyle — a third of what breaststroke costs.

Swimmer lifting out of the water during a butterfly stroke
Photo by Sergio Benavides on Pexels

Butterfly has a reputation as the stroke for the strong, which is mostly wrong. It is the stroke for the well-timed. Get the rhythm right and it is hard work; get it wrong and it is impossible, regardless of how much you can bench.

Almost all of the difference is in where two kicks land, and the published time standards back that up: in the USA Swimming tables the 100 butterfly sits only 6.7% to 8.6% behind the 100 freestyle from age 13 up, against 13.8% to 29.1% at 10 and under. The stroke is not expensive. Not knowing it is.

What the rule book actually says about butterfly

Butterfly is the most tightly defined of the four strokes, and reading the actual articles is worth ten minutes because three of the commonest beliefs about it are not in there.

These are the World Aquatics Competition Regulations in force from February 2026, Part Two, Article 8.

ArticleWhat it requires
8.1, 8.2Body on the breast from the first arm stroke after the start and each turn. No rolling onto the back, except at the turn after touching the wall.
8.3Both arms forward simultaneously over the water, backward simultaneously under it, throughout the race.
8.4All up and down leg movements simultaneous. The legs or feet need not be on the same level, but must not alternate. No breaststroke kicking movement.
8.5Turn and finish touched with both hands separated and simultaneously. "Separated" means not stacked one on top of the other — no visible gap needed, incidental contact at the fingers allowed.
8.6Some part of the body must break the surface throughout, except during the turn and for up to 15 m off each wall, where you get unlimited kicks but only one arm pull.

Two things in there surprise people. Your feet do not have to be level — Article 8.4 says so explicitly, and what is illegal is an alternating action, not an uneven one. And one arm pull underwater, not two: the kicks off the wall are unlimited inside 15 m, the pull is not, and that is the rule most often broken by adults who learned the stroke informally. Breaststroke works the other way round — one pull, one kick, and no 15 m limit at all.

What the regulations remove is the improvisation available in other strokes: you cannot quietly turn a struggling butterfly into a modified freestyle. And because both arms recover at once, there is a moment in every cycle when nothing is propelling you. Everything depends on arriving at that moment with momentum.

Where the two rule books disagree, and it matters in a Masters meet

Article 8.4 of the World Aquatics regulations forbids a breaststroke kicking movement in butterfly outright. The 2026 U.S. Masters Swimming rule book says the opposite in article 101.3.3: the breaststroke kick "may be used exclusively or interchangeably with the dolphin kick while doing the butterfly stroke at any time during the race", at one kick per arm pull.

So the same stroke is legal at a USMS meet and a disqualification at a World Aquatics one. It is a deliberate Masters allowance for swimmers whose shoulders or backs will not take a repeated dolphin action — but it means knowing which rule set your event is swum under, and the entry information says so. The mirror-image detail, that a single dolphin kick is permitted in breaststroke off each wall, is in the breaststroke kick guide.

So if a coach suggests swimming butterfly with a breaststroke kick to protect a sore back, that is a real option in Masters competition rather than a training-only exercise — but check the meet rules before you count on it.

The two kicks, and what each is for

This is the core of it. There are two kicks per arm cycle, and they are not interchangeable.

Kick one lands as the hands enter the water at the front of the stroke. Its job is to press the hips up and set the body position for the catch. Miss it and you enter flat and low.

Kick two lands as the hands finish the pull and leave the water at the back. Its job is to drive the hips down so the chest and shoulders rise — which is what carries your arms up and over for the recovery.

The second one changes everything for adult learners. The recovery is not lifted by the shoulders. It is thrown by the second kick. If your arms feel like lead by the fourth stroke, this is almost certainly why: you are performing with muscle a movement that is supposed to be free.

Frequently asked questions

How many kicks are there per stroke?

Two, and they do different jobs. The first lands roughly as the hands enter the water at the front. The second lands as the hands finish the pull and leave the water at the back. Swimmers who kick once per cycle, or who kick at random, find butterfly enormously harder than it needs to be.

Why can I not get my arms out of the water?

Because you are asking your shoulders to do a job the second kick is supposed to do. That kick drives the hips down and the upper body up, and the recovery rides on that momentum. Without it you are lifting two tired arms out of the water with muscle alone, which nobody can sustain.

Is butterfly really the hardest stroke?

Not by the published numbers. In the USA Swimming motivational standards the 100 butterfly sits 6.7% to 8.6% behind the 100 freestyle from age 13 up, while the 100 breaststroke sits 23.6% to 26.1% behind. Butterfly feels hardest because bad timing is expensive, not because the stroke is slow.

How many dolphin kicks can I take off the wall?

As many as you like within the first 15 metres, but only one arm pull, and your head must break the surface by the 15 metre mark. That is World Aquatics article 8.6. The limit most adults break is the pull, not the kicks.

Is a breaststroke kick allowed in butterfly?

It depends on the rule set. World Aquatics article 8.4 forbids it. U.S. Masters Swimming article 101.3.3 allows it, one kick per arm pull, as a deliberate concession for swimmers who cannot repeat a dolphin action. Check which rules your meet is swum under.

Do I need to be strong to swim butterfly?

Less than you would think. Butterfly punishes bad timing far more than it rewards strength, which is why some slight swimmers make it look easy and some strong ones cannot complete a length. Strength helps at speed; timing determines whether the stroke works at all.

Why does my lower back hurt?

Usually because the undulation is coming from arching the back rather than from the hips, and often because the head is lifting too high to breathe. It is a signal to stop and rebuild the stroke in short pieces, not to push through — and if it persists, to see a professional.

Read next

SwimFast is an independent publication. We are not a swim school, a coaching service or a governing body, and nothing here is medical advice. Training paces and test protocols are cited from the published research or federation documents linked on each page. Never swim alone, never attempt breath-hold work without supervision, and check with a doctor before starting a new training programme.